The departure of Javier Mascherano from Inter Miami has reignited debate about the most successful head coach in club history.
The answer, at least statistically, is clear: Mascherano and Gerardo Martino are tied for the most wins ever by an Inter Miami manager, each finishing with 38 victories across all competitions.
That shared mark reflects two different but equally impactful eras for a relatively young franchise. Founded in 2018 and beginning play in 2020, Miami has experienced rapid growth, both on and off the field. Backed by ownership led by David Beckham, the club has gone from expansion side to trophy contender in just a few seasons, and both Martino and Mascherano played key roles in that evolution.
Martino led the way and Mascherano replicated it
Martino‘s tenure from mid-2023 to late 2024 laid the foundation for the club’s rise. He coached 67 matches, compiling a record of 38 wins, 13 draws, and 16 losses. His most notable achievement came in the 2023 Leagues Cup, where Inter Miami captured its first major trophy, highlighted by a dramatic final victory over Nashville SC. Martino also oversaw a dominant 2024 MLS regular season, guiding the team to a Supporters' Shield with 22 wins and a club-record 74 points.
Mascherano followed with a nearly identical statistical output but a different kind of success. Also managing 67 matches, he recorded 38 wins, 15 draws, and 14 losses, slightly improving the team’s consistency by reducing defeats. More importantly, he delivered the club’s first MLS Cup title in 2025, along with an Eastern Conference championship. Under his leadership, Inter set an attacking benchmark with 101 goals in a single season, showcasing a high-powered style that maximized the talent of players like Lionel Messi.
While both coaches share the wins record, their legacies are shaped by different milestones. Martino brought the club its first piece of silverware and established it as a legitimate contender. Mascherano elevated that foundation into a championship-winning team, proving he could succeed in his first club head coaching role after working with Argentina‘s youth national teams.
Ver esta publicación en Instagram
Great leader but not so great achievements
Other managers in club history provide context but fall short of those achievements. Phil Neville managed the most matches in team history with 90, guiding Inter Miami through its early years but finishing with 36 wins. Diego Alonso, the club’s first head coach, oversaw its inaugural season and helped establish its competitive identity, while interim coach Javier Morales had only a brief stint.
As of now, the top of the record books remains shared. Both Martino and Mascherano have 38 wins, the most in Inter Miami history, but their contributions reflect different stages of the club’s development. Martino built the platform, and Mascherano delivered the ultimate prize.
With Mascherano now stepping away,Inter Miami enters a new phase. Matching or surpassing that 38-win benchmark will be the next challenge for whoever takes over, but the standard has clearly been set by two Argentine coaches who helped define the club’s early success.
