Penalties Can Be Cruel. How Will The USA Approach Them?

Laken Litman College Football & Soccer Analyst

SAN JOSE, Calif. – Malik Tillman likes watching penalty shootouts. But participating in them? Not so much.

"I try to avoid it," the American midfielder said before training on Tuesday. "Everyone tries to avoid it. But sometimes, it happens and, of course, you have to be ready for it because you never know. We’ll give our best to finish the game in 90 minutes.

The U.S. men's national team faces Bosnia and Herzegovina in the Round of 32 at San Francisco Bay Area Stadium on Wednesday night. With the World Cup now in the knockout stage, any match that remains tied after regulation and extra time comes down to one thing: the dreaded stomach-churning penalty shootout.

On Monday, Germany and the Netherlands were both sent home after cruel and dramatic penalty shootout losses to Paraguay and Morocco, respectively. Across the two shootouts, players missed 10 penalty kicks, setting a World Cup record for the most misses in a single day.

It was a stark reminder of the stakes now facing the U.S. because, in the knockout stage, one mistake can send a team home.

"We’ve seen two big boys fall," defender Chris Richards told a group of reporters. "So it’s just a matter of us getting through this game and putting on a good performance and, hopefully, we continue that."

The last time the USA found itself in a penalty shootout was exactly one year ago, when it beat Costa Rica in the 2025 Concacaf Gold Cup quarterfinals after a six-round thriller. The win came largely thanks to Matt Freese’s heroics in goal, as he made three saves to send the squad through.

Tillman, who missed a penalty in the first half of that match, bounced back by converting in the shootout. He said that while players can practice penalties all they want, it’s "impossible" to replicate what it actually feels like in that spotlight.

"You can never really train those moments," Tillman said. "Of course, there’s a lot of pressure, but I think it also depends on the game and how the game went, how you feel, and then either you’re more confident or maybe a little less confident."

Tillman explained that the penalty kicking order is set by manager Mauricio Pochettino and the coaching staff, who analyze players’ spot-kick work in training before deciding who steps up.

Malik Tillman and the art of the penalty. (Photo by Omar Vega/USSF/Getty Images)

According to a German media report, there was controversy over who would take Germany’s sixth penalty, as some players didn’t want to. Ultimately, it was Jonathan Tah whose miss proved decisive and allowed Paraguay to convert and advance.

"I don’t know about that situation, but yeah, it’s a difficult thing," star forward Christian Pulisic said when asked about Germany’s exit. "The guys who feel the most confident to go up and shoot will want to go shoot. I think that’s normal. There will be some players that maybe don’t practice them as much and don’t feel as good. I don’t think it’s necessarily a big problem.

"Haven’t been in many shootouts with these guys, but I feel like it’s a pretty brave, courageous team. I feel like guys will give it a go."

How Do USA Players Take Penalties?

Penalty kick style and technique have evolved over the years. Some players opt for stutter steps and elaborate long or short run-ups, while others simply place the ball and strike it.

Tillman said he’s experimented with different approaches throughout his career and doesn’t necessarily take them the same way he once did. Still, he added, "I’m confident in the way I take them."

Richards, who scored a penalty for Premier League club Crystal Palace last season, doesn’t overthink it.

"I don’t want to give away too much," Richards said with a big smile. "Some guys change it up. Me personally, I’m a defender for a reason, so I’m gonna put it down and place it where I think it needs to go."

Chris Richards and Matt Freese were part of the USA's penalties against Costa Rica at the 2025 Gold Cup. (Photo by Carlos Gonzalez/ISI Photos/USSF/Getty Images)

Pulisic doesn’t read too much into everyone else’s process.

"Everyone has their own style," said Pulisic, who also noted that he’s feeling good after dealing with a calf injury that has limited his time on the field. "I don’t think you watch [the Germany and Netherlands shootouts] and can take so much away and try to change your style in one day. I mean, it’s just part of the game.

"It’s an extremely hard thing to do for sure. It takes a lot of courage and it's not easy. Goalkeepers are getting better and better every single year. Everyone has their individual style, and you just go with what you feel most confident with."

All this is to say, the U.S. hopes any penalty shootout talk is moot during their run in this World Cup.

"Ultimately, you don’t want to get there," Richards said. "But honestly, we’ve done a lot of training with penalty shootouts, so if it comes down to it, I think every guy on this team is going to step up and take it."

Zlatan & Thierry Henry Preview United States’ Round of 32 Matchup vs Bosnia and Herzegovina

share
recommended

1. 
   

   Brazil, Germany, Netherlands Ready For A Supercharged Round Of 32 Slate

   

   2026 World Cup Bracket: Full Round Of 32 Matchups

   

   Big Bets Report: World Cup Wagering Continues At Blistering Pace

2. 
   

   Martinelli Saves The Day: 4 Takeaways From Brazil's Clutch Win vs. Japan

   

   Chris 'The Bear' Fallica's World Cup Best Bets Today — Match Day 19

   

   Should Disallowed Germany Goal vs. Paraguay Have Counted? 'They Got That Wrong'

3. 
   

   5 Takeaways From Paraguay's Upset Win vs. Germany In The Round Of 32

   

   Alexi Lalas' 2026 FIFA World Cup Bracket Prediction

   

   USA's Path To 2026 World Cup Final: Latest Projected Opponents For Round Of 16 And On

Arrow pointing to the leftArrow pointing to the right

Item 1 of 3 Get more from the FIFA Men's World Cup Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more in this topic United States FIFA Men's World Cup Christian Pulisic Laken Litman
NEXT STORY

recommended

1. 
   

   Brazil, Germany, Netherlands Ready For A Supercharged Round Of 32 Slate

   

   2026 World Cup Bracket: Full Round Of 32 Matchups

   

   Big Bets Report: World Cup Wagering Continues At Blistering Pace

2. 
   

   Martinelli Saves The Day: 4 Takeaways From Brazil's Clutch Win vs. Japan

   

   Chris 'The Bear' Fallica's World Cup Best Bets Today — Match Day 19

   

   Should Disallowed Germany Goal vs. Paraguay Have Counted? 'They Got That Wrong'

3. 
   

   5 Takeaways From Paraguay's Upset Win vs. Germany In The Round Of 32

   

   Alexi Lalas' 2026 FIFA World Cup Bracket Prediction

   

   USA's Path To 2026 World Cup Final: Latest Projected Opponents For Round Of 16 And On

Arrow pointing to the leftArrow pointing to the right

Item 1 of 3Original Article